Saturday, 13 January 2018

The Future: On-Land Fish Farms, NL



The on-land industry is getting so large that in-ocean is starting to dwindle away as industry itself, along with consumers who want fish from on-land sources. 

I mentioned Atlantic Sapphire being built on land in Florida as the biggest in the world. But it is by no means alone. My list has 201 on-land fish farms systems, comprising 20,000 around the world: https://fishfarmnews.blogspot.ca/2016/05/152-different-on-land-fish-farm-systems.html. AS is item 176.

Here are some links for you to go and see about Atlantic Sapphire, text by Bill Bryden from NL:

This is what growing an aquaculture industry looks like; please see the video below by Atlantic Sapphire. Starting at the current 10, 000mt in phase one currently under construction, and rapidly expanding through phase 2 at 30,000mt (more than we have ever produced in NL) and then phase 3 at 90,000 mt.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N75ljbpSBYc
Jan 11 2018 
http://www.intrafish.com/aquaculture/1410587/atlantic-sapphire-moves-forward-with-us-farm-as-crucial-first-steps-successful
Now, that will give you an idea of what the  AS plant looks like and you begin to see that the industry is changing. There are more of course, and Bill is trying to get the Premier Dwight Ball to stop for long enough to see that on-land is the way of the future and that the degradation of in-ocean will end. The point is to keep Grieg et al from getting into the water in the first place and keep NL from conflicting itself by giving Grieg $45 million to destroy Placentia Bay.

Here is more, and surprisingly, Aqua Maof is an on land company, while Grieg wants to use it for an on-land hatchery in NL, but still go into the ocean with 11, 2M fish farms. Note that Maof is building a 20,000mt plant in Virgina, right now, as in blowing in-ocean out of the water:
 
If that is not embarrassing enough perhaps a second site being built by the SAME COMPANY THAT IS BUILDING THE CONTROVERSIAL GRIEG HATCHERY in NL will catch your attention? Isn't this exactly what everyone wants, land based closed containment?
Do you have a subscription to Intrafish? If not, below is that article about Maof from my earlier email. Yes the same Maof that is contracted to build the Grieg hatchery in Placentia.
Re: http://aquamaof.com/newsEventsCanada.asp 

Soo, why are they building a massive 20,000mt totally land based facility in Virginia? Surely if its viable in Virginia it is viable here in NL to take advantage of our infrastructure, distribution channels, exchange rate, cheap labour, free land and freshwater, and access to the lucrative Canadian and New England markets? Why didn't it go here?

I can give you more than 4 BILLION cheap dirty reasons why... https://www.thetelegram.com/opinion/letter-to-the-editor/letter-viking-invasion--the-sad-second-saga-176323/ Now how much of that 4+ billion will go back to the political parties in some way? The government's offer of yet another $45M in investment as shares in the operation is just insurance that they'll get to keep their net pens, be allowed to use insane levels of antibiotics and neurotoxins unlike in Norway and never have to worry about things like sea lice limits and fines/bad press. ($10M by ACOA has also been earmarked)

Anyway, here is the sad and sordid story as just leaked by an interview with Intrafish at a recent conference.

"Yoav Dagan, vice president of Israeli recirculation aquaculture systems (RAS) supplier AquaMaof, has a strong stance on what he believes will be the future of fish farming. According to him, the big money is to be made on land.The company, which Dogan owns together with his brother, reported sales close to $200 million (€166 million) in 2017 -- a massive jump from the $20 million (€16.6 million) it started out with at its very early beginnings.</p> <p>“We’re growing 400 percent in turnover every year; Dagan told during a recent tour through AquaMaof's operations in Israel. Within three to four years, he believes, overall revenue will hit more than $1 billion (€830 million).It's a big target, but an achievable one, he said: the land-based and RAS movement is gaining momentum all over the globe. 

[Now, please excuse that the next section has all the html stuff from the web:]

AquaMaof began with the Dagan brothers producing equipment for their pond fish farm at the Kibbutz Ma'agan Michael in Binyamina, Israel, that produces tilapia, carp, mullet and red drum, starting more than 17 years ago. </p> <p>&quot;It was a spin-off,&quot; Dagan said. &quot;We've been developing the technology for ourselves because we were struggling with what was available.&quot;</p> <h2 data-element-type="subhead">Investment spree</h2> <p>Around five years ago the company changed its strategy, moving on from being a sole equipment supplier to investing in projects it builds for its clients -- and consequently became part owners in a number of them. </p> <p>In addition, it the company is initiating new projects &quot;in interesting markets,&quot; Dagan said. That way, AquaMaof works on about five to seven new projects each year. </p> <p>Today it has ownership in a Slovakian fish farm -- the Rybia Farm -- which produces 1,000 metric tons of catfish annually and started operating in 2015. </p> <p>The project is part of an agricultural complex combined by fish processing plant and vegetables greenhouses. </p> <p>Another investment is in a 500-metric tons RAS farm in Russia, which operates under F Trout and is already building a second one. </p> <p>AquaMaof recently also started operating a 2,000 metric tons capacity sea bream farm, located in the Israeli Negev desert two years ago. </p> <p>&quot;We built it because we wanted to prove that we can farm fish anywhere,&quot; Dagan said of the project. </p> <p>AquaMaof's best-known project is Polish firm Global Fish, which <a contenteditabe="true" href="http://www.intrafish.com/news/638893/land-based-farmer-targets-eu-tilapia-market" target="_blank">originally reared tilapia in the RAS farm</a>. Dagan and his brother <a contenteditabe="true" href="http://www.intrafish.com/news/646898/polish-land-based-producer-calls-it-quits-on-tilapia" target="_blank">bought the company out two years ago</a> as the previous owners faced issues with marketing the fish. 
Israeli group nabs deal for $57 million Grieg salmon facility

The facility is now used as an R&D site for Atlantic salmon farming, Dagan said. We will sell the fish at some point but the main goal is research. This is also in preparation for a massive 20,000 metric tons capacity land-based salmon farm it is planning to construct in Virginia, the United States. Land and licenses have already been acquired but it is still waiting for the permits to get construction started, Dagan said. Another project is a grouper farm in Indonesia, which is currently under construction with a local partner and set to start operating this year.</p> <p>&quot;Our philosophy is to produce away from the sea and close to the markets,&quot; he explained the strategy. The European Union, the United States and southeast Asia are the obvious ones but Dagan said he &quot;really believes in undeveloped countries&quot; such as Nigeria as well as East African countries. </p> <h2 data-element-type="subhead">Banking big on R&amp;D</h2> <p>Dagan foresees a great future for two species in land-based fish farming: Atlantic salmon and grouper. Cafish, which is &quot;very rigid and easy to farm,&quot; as well as brramundi and trout are also on the list of targeted species by AquaMaof.</p> <p>The company is currently also conducting research into land-based shrimp farming and is planning to launch a pilot project with 150 metric tons of high-density production in Israel. </p> <p>The company also researched bluefin tuna for the last seven years with Virginia Tech and other researchers in Israel and Dagan said the team is on the right track. </p> <p>&quot;We will be there, soon hopefully,&quot; he said. </p> <p>He was adamant to stress that AquaMaof was &quot;built on strong people,&quot; who have the freedom for trial and error, for innovation and showing initiative.</p> <p>The company is run by CEO David Hazut, who served in the Israeli army with Dagan. Neder Snir is the chief technology officer (CTO) and Gary Myers oversees operations as US director and senior CTO. </p> <p>&quot;Our philosophy is not about just building at farm, it's about making a project successful after it's been established,&quot; Dagan said. &quot;And there's a lot of people behind carrying the company."


PS note they also have an operations in Russia ((500mt as F-trout) that is undergoing a doubling of production and Poland (550mt) http://www.globalfish.pl/en/fresh-salmon.html  Neither of which I had heard of before. Every time I turn around I find more significant land based salmon and trout operations hiding around the planet. China (x3), Switzerland, Denmark (x11), USA (x3), BC, NS, France, Scotland, Norway, Poland (x2), etc Some are massive and rapidly expanding...
Fresh Salmon – Raised in Poland. - Globalfish

Premier...PLEASE get better advisers. These people you have around you have sunk every aspect of their reputation and careers into making the lead balloon that is open net pen aquaculture fly. Get rid of them before they take YOU, US, and our once pristine bays and wild fish stocks down with them. They now have to admit they backed an ecocidal idea that was the "wrong horse" - something they will never do.

Sockeye Can't Catch Fish Farm Viruses? - Well, NO

DFO has been spreading untrue info, or at least, the press has reported DFO spreading untrue information. What has been said is that sockeye can't catch fish farm viruses. So, no problem right? Well, no. the real story is that DFO has come out with text that says sockeye can't catch IHN from farmed salmon that have been vaccinated against IHN. That is quite a different thing. 


Fish are not vaccinated as we are with a shot to the arm, er, fin of every human/fish. It can be injected, which is costly, as it is for IHN, but the vaccine can be put in their feed, or an immersion bath and that is a far cry from vaccination as we do it in humans. And all that DFO can mean is that a vaccinated fish can't get the disease. But what it doesn't add is the obvious thing that makes the intention of this announcement simply for its spin value: the fish can pass the same virus on to other fish even when it doesn't get sick itself.

Furthermore, there are several dozen fish farm viruses, bacteria, parasites, lice, etc. that wild fish can catch from fish farm fish, so the story should not have been released and made to sound like the problem with fish farms is all over. The announcement should not have been made and should not have been reported on.

An example is the Jan 10, 2018 article in the TC newspaper, which is a follow up piece to the original news that made the rounds a week earlier. The article is: Scientist pans fish disease review, by Amy Smart. It's enough to make someone cynical. Listen up:

Stan Proboszcz, science adviser for Watershed Watch says the process lacked transparency, and scientists were not allowed to read a fish farm company fish management report that DFO used to make this announcement.

"That's contradictory to the peer review process," he said and is a complete lack of transparency. And, you should know that Stan was on the DFO steering committee that gives scientific advice to DFO; however, if you can believe it, were not given the report to read, only a summary of the agreement, that companies would allow their fish to be tested. That is quite a different thing from the actual research document. The agreement is not about science, only giving permission to use fish.

Yes, DFO puffed up its chest and said it is only one 'robust' investigation underway (of 10, or so it says) to prove that fish farm diseases are harmless to wild salmon. Is it just me that thinks they have this backward? Doesn't it just continue what Cohen told them not to do, and make sure to take out fish farm cheer leading from DFO entirely, as it is incompatible with its primary role under the Wild Salmon Policy?

Calling it robust is silly. That is spin. It's obvious that vaccinating someone's fish would mean most shouldn't get disease and the farm would not be leaking 56 billion viral particles per hour, but noting that the fish were vaccinated is a million miles away from doing robust science.

What about all the research, by DFO, for instance, that Fraser sockeye are dying from pre-spawn mortality, have PRV, and that DFO scientist Kristi Miller showed that PRV causes HSMI, something that fish farms, BCMAL, the testing system, and DFO continue to deny? That's the real story here, that DFO is in a conflict of interest.

Smart's article notes one of the typical non-transparencies in fish farm issues - one should always assume that where a fish farm says it is transparent, that you should add the 'non' in front of the word. The Cohen requirement for the disease tables in his Commission is an example: he asked for disease tables, fish farms sent in lawyers (standard practice) to argue he should not get them, he required them anyway, and fish farms trumpeted how transparent they were, then Cohen required individual disease sheets, not simply summary documents and they sent in the lawyers again, saying he did not have authority to require them. He required them anyway and that led off the explosive third disease section of the proceedings.

During that session the best scientists, Miller, Nylund and Kibenge, noted how bad the DFO and CFIA labs were, including the Winnipeg, Gagne lab. And poor Kim Klottins from the CFIA got cornered into saying it didn't want to find disease because that would affect the exportability of the fish, to the USA for instance. Another riveting moment was when Miller said that fish farms could be 'the smoking gun'. The look on her face when she realized what she had just said was worth the price tag of the $36 Million commission.

Now, back to the current story. So, what did DFO say about releasing the report supporting the agreement? It said: 'because it's considered a confidential business document, government staff are prohibited from releasing it.' Is it just me who notes this is non- and even un-transparent? It's the old 'proprietary' information spin that is used all around the world to avoid being transparent.

So, even the DFO committee could not look at the DFO report. Hmm. And you can only get on this committee if you are invited by DFO to be on it. Hmm. And the neat DFO quote on the non-transparency is: "A key element of our science peer review is [wait for it] transparency. DFO provides all science advice and supporting document from its peer reviews on its website." Hmm.

So, what this means is DFO won't give the 'robust' research to their own committee, but DFO is transparent because the 'consensus' document that comes out of that committee that can't look at the 'robust' science is on its website. Hmm.

Oh, and DFO went on to say that Proboszcz could request the original 'robust' material directly from the companies that signed it. Is that hilarious or what? Too bad we don't have Cohen to 'require' the material and so the companies, Marine Harvest, Cermaq, and Grieg Seafood can decline to send it forward. Hmm.

* 

One more thing, Living Oceans has done a news release on this issue, too: https://www.watershed-watch.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Federal_Science_Mired-media_release-Jan8_2018.pdf.

*

One more thing: here is the letter from Stan P. from Watershed Watch after the TC article, saying he can now speak freely In other words, DFO is still in a big conflict of interest with fish farms. Please sign the petition. Stan is not pleased: 

Dear DC,

In 2015, I was asked to be on a government science steering committee examining Infectious Hematopoietic Necrosis Virus (or IHNV for short) from salmon farms and its risk to wild salmon.

Of course, I had concerns about being on a government-led committee, especially after the Cohen Inquiry into the Decline of Fraser Sockeye Salmon concluded that DFO may have a pro-salmon farming bias. Despite my reservations, I accepted the role, and the confidentiality of the position.

Now that the steering committee has published their final report, I’m free to tell you about my experiences.

The report concluded that the risk of IHNV from salmon farms was minimal, based on the industry’s virus management practices. Here’s the kicker. The details of the industry’s management practices that substantiate the conclusions were confidential, so we couldn’t review this information. When I asked to see the documents, a DFO scientist denied me access. This is contradictory to what a scientific peer-review should be.

That’s not all. At the peer-review meeting, on three separate occasions, I witnessed scientists who appeared uncomfortable in sharing their views on salmon farming issues and refrained. What kind of scientific peer-review is DFO running? One where secret industry information is used to support pro-industry conclusions? And where scientists don’t feel safe to speak freely and honestly about salmon farms?

After seeing firsthand how DFO produces its science, I have much skepticism about this report’s benign conclusions about IHNV. We don't know whether IHNV from salmon farms is harming wild fish, in part because the information can’t be reviewed.

This will all come to a head soon. DFO is proceeding with more of these flawed science reviews on other pathogens, despite my criticisms in the peer-review sessions and on CFAX radio and in the Times Colonist.

We need precautionary action from our government, not biased science that protects industry secrets. Wild salmon need to be defended from the diseases and parasites of fish farms.

Our Safe Passage petition calls for the removal of fish farms from wild salmon migration routes. Can you help us get to 10,000 signatures by the end of January by signing and sharing it with friends, family and co-workers?

We’ve heard rumours that DFO may begin consultations for new aquaculture legislation sometime early this year. We need to be ready with loads of engaged citizens, collectively calling for the protection of our wild salmon.

Can you sign and share our petition? Help us reach 10,000 signatures on the Safe Passage and together we’ll make big waves in 2018!

In solidarity,
Stan Proboszcz



Thursday, 11 January 2018

PRV In Wild Salmon - Infected by Farmed Salmon

This is the paper: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0188793. December 2017.

This is the abstract:

Abstract

The disease Heart and Skeletal Muscle Inflammation (HSMI) is causing substantial economic losses to the Norwegian salmon farming industry where the causative agent, piscine orthoreovirus (PRV), is reportedly spreading from farmed to wild Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) with as yet undetermined impacts. To assess if PRV infection is epidemiologically linked between wild and farmed salmon in the eastern Pacific, wild Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus sp.) from regions designated as high or low exposure to salmon farms and farmed Atlantic salmon reared in British Columbia (BC) were tested for PRV. The proportion of PRV infection in wild fish was related to exposure to salmon farms (p = 0.0097). PRV was detected in: 95% of farmed Atlantic salmon, 37–45% of wild salmon from regions highly exposed to salmon farms and 5% of wild salmon from the regions furthest from salmon farms. The proportion of PRV infection was also significantly lower (p = 0.0008) where wild salmon had been challenged by an arduous return migration into high-elevation spawning habitat. Inter-annual PRV infection declined in both wild and farmed salmon from 2012–2013 (p ≤ 0.002). These results suggest that PRV transfer is occurring from farmed Atlantic salmon to wild Pacific salmon, that infection in farmed salmon may be influencing infection rates in wild salmon, and that this may pose a risk of reduced fitness in wild salmon impacting their survival and reproduction.

Here is a figure on the percent infection:



Comments: To come.

Wednesday, 10 January 2018

Sockeye Can't Catch Fish Farm Viruses? - Well, NO

DFO has been spreading untrue info, or at least, the press has reported DFO spreading untrue information. What has been said is that sockeye can't catch fish farm viruses. So, no problem right? Well, no. the real story is that DFO has come out with text that says sockeye can't catch IHN from farmed salmon that have been vaccinated against IHN. That is quite a different thing. 


Fish are not vaccinated as we are with a shot to the arm, er, fin of every human/fish. It can be injected, which is costly, as it is for IHN, but the vaccine can be put in their feed, or an immersion bath and that is a far cry from vaccination as we do it in humans. And all that DFO can mean is that a vaccinated fish can't get the disease. But what it doesn't add is the obvious thing that makes the intention of this announcement simply for its spin value: the fish can pass the same virus on to other fish even when it doesn't get sick itself.

Furthermore, there are several dozen fish farm viruses, bacteria, parasites, lice, etc. that wild fish can catch from fish farm fish, so the story should not have been released and made to sound like the problem with fish farms is all over. The announcement should not have been made and should not have been reported on.

An example is the Jan 10, 2018 article in the TC newspaper, which is a follow up piece to the original news that made the rounds a week earlier. The article is: Scientist pans fish disease review, by Amy Smart. It's enough to make someone cynical. Listen up:

Stan Proboszcz, science adviser for Watershed Watch says the process lacked transparency, and scientists were not allowed to read a fish farm company fish management report that DFO used to make this announcement.

"That's contradictory to the peer review process," he said and is a complete lack of transparency. And, you should know that Stan was on the DFO steering committee that gives scientific advice to DFO; however, if you can believe it, were not given the report to read, only a summary of the agreement, that companies would allow their fish to be tested. That is quite a different thing from the actual research document. The agreement is not about science, only giving permission to use fish.

Yes, DFO puffed up its chest and said it is only one 'robust' investigation underway (of 10, or so it says) to prove that fish farm diseases are harmless to wild salmon. Is it just me that thinks they have this backward? Doesn't it just continue what Cohen told them not to do, and make sure to take out fish farm cheer leading from DFO entirely, as it is incompatible with its primary role under the Wild Salmon Policy?

Calling it robust is silly. That is spin. It's obvious that vaccinating someone's fish would mean most shouldn't get disease and the farm would not be leaking 56 billion viral particles per hour, but noting that the fish were vaccinated is a million miles away from doing robust science.

What about all the research, by DFO, for instance, that Fraser sockeye are dying from pre-spawn mortality, have PRV, and that DFO scientist Kristi Miller showed that PRV causes HSMI, something that fish farms, BCMAL, the testing system, and DFO continue to deny? That's the real story here, that DFO is in a conflict of interest.

Smart's article notes one of the typical non-transparencies in fish farm issues - one should always assume that where a fish farm says it is transparent, that you should add the 'non' in front of the word. The Cohen requirement for the disease tables in his Commission is an example: he asked for disease tables, fish farms sent in lawyers (standard practice) to argue he should not get them, he required them anyway, and fish farms trumpeted how transparent they were, then Cohen required individual disease sheets, not simply summary documents and they sent in the lawyers again, saying he did not have authority to require them. He required them anyway and that led off the explosive third disease section of the proceedings.

During that session the best scientists, Miller, Nylund and Kibenge, noted how bad the DFO and CFIA labs were, including the Winnipeg, Gagne lab. And poor Kim Klottins from the CFIA got cornered into saying it didn't want to find disease because that would affect the exportability of the fish, to the USA for instance. Another riveting moment was when Miller said that fish farms could be 'the smoking gun'. The look on her face when she realized what she had just said was worth the price tag of the $36 Million commission.

Now, back to the current story. So, what did DFO say about releasing the report supporting the agreement? It said: 'because it's considered a confidential business document, government staff are prohibited from releasing it.' Is it just me who notes this is non- and even un-transparent? It's the old 'proprietary' information spin that is used all around the world to avoid being transparent.

So, even the DFO committee could not look at the DFO report. Hmm. And you can only get on this committee if you are invited by DFO to be on it. Hmm. And the neat DFO quote on the non-transparency is: "A key element of our science peer review is [wait for it] transparency. DFO provides all science advice and supporting document from its peer reviews on its website." Hmm.

So, what this means is DFO won't give the 'robust' research to their own committee, but DFO is transparent because the 'consensus' document that comes out of that committee that can't look at the 'robust' science is on its website. Hmm.

Oh, and DFO went on to say that Proboszcz could request the original 'robust' material directly from the companies that signed it. Is that hilarious or what? Too bad we don't have Cohen to 'require' the material and so the companies, Marine Harvest, Cermaq, and Grieg Seafood can decline to send it forward. Hmm.

* 

One more thing, Living Oceans has done a news release on this issue, too: https://www.watershed-watch.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Federal_Science_Mired-media_release-Jan8_2018.pdf.

*

One more thing: here is the letter from Stan P. from Watershed Watch after the TC article, saying he can now speak freely In other words, DFO is still in a big conflict of interest with fish farms. Please sign the petition. Stan is not pleased. Please note that DFO should be considered the enemy of Wild Pacific salmon in BC. I am reluctant to say that but it is true.

Dear DC,

In 2015, I was asked to be on a government science steering committee examining Infectious Hematopoietic Necrosis Virus (or IHNV for short) from salmon farms and its risk to wild salmon.

Of course, I had concerns about being on a government-led committee, especially after the Cohen Inquiry into the Decline of Fraser Sockeye Salmon concluded that DFO may have a pro-salmon farming bias. Despite my reservations, I accepted the role, and the confidentiality of the position.

Now that the steering committee has published their final report, I’m free to tell you about my experiences.

The report concluded that the risk of IHNV from salmon farms was minimal, based on the industry’s virus management practices. Here’s the kicker. The details of the industry’s management practices that substantiate the conclusions were confidential, so we couldn’t review this information. When I asked to see the documents, a DFO scientist denied me access. This is contradictory to what a scientific peer-review should be.

That’s not all. At the peer-review meeting, on three separate occasions, I witnessed scientists who appeared uncomfortable in sharing their views on salmon farming issues and refrained. What kind of scientific peer-review is DFO running? One where secret industry information is used to support pro-industry conclusions? And where scientists don’t feel safe to speak freely and honestly about salmon farms?

After seeing firsthand how DFO produces its science, I have much skepticism about this report’s benign conclusions about IHNV. We don't know whether IHNV from salmon farms is harming wild fish, in part because the information can’t be reviewed.

This will all come to a head soon. DFO is proceeding with more of these flawed science reviews on other pathogens, despite my criticisms in the peer-review sessions and on CFAX radio and in the Times Colonist.

We need precautionary action from our government, not biased science that protects industry secrets. Wild salmon need to be defended from the diseases and parasites of fish farms.

Our Safe Passage petition calls for the removal of fish farms from wild salmon migration routes. Can you help us get to 10,000 signatures by the end of January by signing and sharing it with friends, family and co-workers?

We’ve heard rumours that DFO may begin consultations for new aquaculture legislation sometime early this year. We need to be ready with loads of engaged citizens, collectively calling for the protection of our wild salmon.

Can you sign and share our petition? Help us reach 10,000 signatures on the Safe Passage and together we’ll make big waves in 2018!

In solidarity,
Stan Proboszcz