The Cohen Commission Report into declines in the Fraser River sockeye runs has been released.
Here is the news release: http://www.cohencommission.ca/en/NewsReleases/FinalReportReleased.php.
And this statement from it: 'Cohen emphasized that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO)
should fully implement and fund both the 2005 Wild Salmon Policy and
the1986 Habitat Policy. “DFO should develop and publish a detailed
implementation plan
as set out in the Wild Salmon Policy and, without further delay, honour
its commitment to implementation,” he noted. “The goals of the Habitat
Policy and its No Net Loss principle are sound and should be retained.”'
This is a sound recommendation. Anyone who follows salmon issues knows that the Wild Salmon Policy disappeared from view almost immediately after it was written. And the Habitat Policy also contains good information on protecting salmon habitat. It also died an early death. On both issues, DFO has failed badly.
In addition, the Harper government recently gutted the Fisheries Act, the Environmental Protection Act of fish protection as well as began cutting 200 scientists in 2012.
And this statement about fish farms, in the news release preceding the report, states the issue directly and correctly:
'To address the potential conflict for DFO between promoting salmon
farms and regulating them, the Commissioner recommended that DFO no
longer be responsible for promoting salmon farming as an industry and
farmed salmon as a product. “As long as DFO has a mandate to promote
salmon farming, there is a risk that it will act in a manner that
favours the interests of the salmon farming industry over the health of
wild fish stocks,” he said.
The Commissioner concluded that salmon farms along the sockeye migration route
in the Discovery Islands have the potential to introduce exotic
diseases and to aggravate endemic diseases which can have a negative
impact on Fraser River sockeye. “Mitigation measures should not be
delayed in the absence of scientific certainty,” he said.
For that reason, Cohen recommended a freeze on net-pen salmon farm
production in the Discovery Islands until September 30, 2020. “If by
that date, DFO cannot confidently say the risk of serious harm to wild
stocks is minimal, it should then prohibit all net-pen salmon farms from
operating in the Discovery Islands,” he said. Cohen also recommended
that if before September 30, 2020, the government determines that salmon
farms pose more than a minimal risk to Fraser River sockeye, the
government prohibit their operation immediately.'
Here is the report: http://www.cohencommission.ca/en/. Click on the icon and read the 1200 pages of the three volume report. The third volume contains more than 75 recommendations.
Wednesday, 31 October 2012
Friday, 5 October 2012
Salmon Farm Activist Acquitted of Defamation - Oct 4, 1012
Salmon Farm Activist
Acquitted of Defamation
My guess is the average sport fisher does not know who Don
Staniford is. And I venture that Staniford doesn’t know the difference between
a bull head and a bull trout, or even how to catch a salmon. But the roughly
300,000 licenced sport fishers in BC owe him their gratitude. That is because
he has been fearless in his opposition to in-ocean fish farms, particularly in
BC, Scotland, Norway and
other countries.
Staniford’s approach to criticizing the industry that has in
recent months had well-reported disease problems in BC, Washington,
Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, is flamboyant in the extreme
and often foolhardy. His approach lies somewhere between Monty Python and Darth
Vader, with the Energizer Bunny supplying manic energy to his 24-hour a day
activism.
Mainstream Canada
sued him for defamation in February 2012. Judge Adair has just released her
findings. I have excised five pages of relevant clauses from her ruling and you
may find it on my blog, www.fishfarmnews.blogspot.com,
which also contains the link to her 71 page ruling – really worth reading in
its entirety. [Note: the excised comments are the next post on this blog].
Mainstream’s reasons are summarized in clause 10: “Mainstream
claims that, in their natural and ordinary meaning, Mr. Staniford’s statements,
in context, meant and were understood to mean that Mainstream’s business and
products kill people, and that Mainstream is knowingly marketing a carcinogenic
product that causes illness, death and harm. Mainstream says that the “sting”
arising from Mr. Staniford’s publications is that farmed salmon – like smoking
– causes cancer, and that the salmon farming industry is as odious and
dishonest as the tobacco industry.”
Pretty damning
stuff. And Judge Adair roasts Staniford’s character: “[his] value judgments…
[are] prejudiced, exaggerated and obstinate [171].” And, [from 174]: “Mr. Staniford’s judgements have no balance because balance
does not exist in Mr. Staniford’s world when it comes to salmon farming. He has
dedicated himself to eradicating it.” She also found that his comments were
defamatory [118], and that they applied to Mainstream [141].
But at the end, Adair excused Staniford of defamation on the
grounds that he believed what he was saying was true. Having read a lot of what
he has written, I ignore his inflammatory approach and follow-up his links to
the science. They are on the money.
My opinion is that, sadly, the top four problems for ten
species of salmonids are: fish farms, DFO, run of river power and Global
Warming. The last we can do little about quickly, but the other three can be addressed
today with policy decisions. The Cohen Commission into Fraser sockeye collapse
reconvened in December 2011 to assess whether fish farm diseases kill wild
salmon. Its report is due by October 30, 2012. I’ll let you know what it says.
Sport fishers should pat Staniford on the back – he has
withstood being sued three times over the past decade by fish farms, though never
successfully – because his bottom line is to stand with wild salmon in BC. In
fairness, I don’t see that fish farms need to be eradicated - they need to be
on land where their density-related disease amplification affects no other fish
or species. I have found more than 8,000 actual on-land farms around the world,
so there is no technological or economic impediment. We need wild salmon and so
do 37 species of our wild animals like bears and eagles.
560 Words
dcreid@islandnet.com
Sunday, 30 September 2012
Don Staniford Acquitted of Defaming Mainstream Canada, Sept 30, 2012
Judge Adair released her ruling in Mainstream Canada's case accusing Don Staniford of defamation. She found that he had defamed Mainstream, but dismissed the case as she reasoned that he truly believed what he was saying. The last five pages are a quite involved argument.
Find her 71 page ruling here: http://donstaniford.typepad.com/files/judgment-28-september-2012-adair-re-mainstream-canada-v-staniford-09-28.pdf.
Here are some of the most relevant sections for those who do not have the time to read the entire ruling:
Find her 71 page ruling here: http://donstaniford.typepad.com/files/judgment-28-september-2012-adair-re-mainstream-canada-v-staniford-09-28.pdf.
Here are some of the most relevant sections for those who do not have the time to read the entire ruling:
Mainstream Canada vs Don Staniford - Summary
[10]
Mainstream claims that, in their natural and ordinary meaning, Mr. Staniford’s
statements, in context, meant and were understood to mean that Mainstream’s
business and products kill people, and that Mainstream is knowingly marketing a
carcinogenic product that causes illness, death and harm. Mainstream says that
the “sting” arising from Mr. Staniford’s publications is that farmed salmon –
like smoking – causes cancer, and that the salmon farming industry is as odious
and dishonest as the tobacco industry.
[11] Mainstream seeks
substantial
[57] Mainstream pleads over
fifty particulars of defamatory words contained in the publications. These
include the following, many of which appear on mock-cigarette packages (page
references indicate the page(s) in the Schedules to the Amended Claim):
Mainstream Canada v.
Staniford Page 19 a) from the “Salmon Farming Kills”
campaign: “Salmon Farming Kills” (p. 1); “Salmon Farming Seriously Damages
Health” (p. 1, p. 27); “Salmon Farming Licenced to Kill” (p. 3); “Salmon
Farming Kills Around the World and Should Carry a Global Health Warning” (p.
7); “Salmon Farming Seriously Damages Human Health, the Health of our Global
Ocean, and the Health of Wild Fish” (p. 7); “Salmon Farming is Toxic and Poison”
(p. 3); “Salmon Farming is Toxic” (p. 4); “Fish Farmers are playing ‘the same
game as the cigarette manufacturers did for many years’” (p. 1);
(b) from the “Silent Spring
57, c Put a copy of ‘Smoke on
the Water, Cancer in the Coast’ in your pipe and smoke it” (p. 26); “Salmon
Farming Kills Like Smoking” (p. 27); “Salmon Farming . . .
Clause 58: reasonable person as a comment upon true facts,
and not as a bare statement of fact: see Ross, at para. 58 (quoting from Brown, The Law of
Defamation in Canada). In other words, the comment, though it can
include inferences of fact, must be recognizable as comment.
though the comment satisfies the objective test, the defence
can be defeated if the plaintiff proves that the defendant was actuated by
express malice. See WIC, at para. 28.
[59]
The “Salmon Farming Kills” pages contained several mock cigarette packages with
the statement “92% Norwegian Owned.”
[60] Under the heading “Salmon
Farming is Toxic and Poison”, Mr. Staniford repeats a quote from an article in
the Toronto Star (hyperlink underlined):
“I would never feed a child
farmed salmon,” said Canadian scientist David Suzuki (as quoted in The
Toronto Star). “It’s poison!”
Clause 74 and 75 about cancer
causing chemicals in farmed and wild salmon
Mainstream’s defamation claim clause 99 Mainstreams claims
101, 103
[115] In a number of places in
the publications in issue, Mr. Staniford states “Salmon Farming Kills,” and
also that “Salmon Farming Kills Like Smoking.” Mr. Staniford also says that
“Salmon Farming Seriously Damages Health.” These are among the many statements
that Mainstream asserts are defamatory. Moreover, in the “sting” alleged,
Mainstream’s focus is on humans and human health.
[118] I conclude therefore that
Mr. Staniford’s words are capable of bearing a defamatory meaning, as pleaded
in para. 22(a), that “Mainstream’s business and products kill people.”
[120] Mr. Staniford’s words
“Fish Farmers are playing the same game as the cigarette manufacturers did for
many years” are, given the notoriety of the harmful effects of smoking and of
the conduct of “Big Tobacco,” capable of bearing the meanings pleaded in paras.
22(d) (“Mainstream has actively misled, deceived, and lied to the public”), (e)
(“Mainstream is knowingly marketing a carcinogenic product that causes illness,
death, and harm”) and (j) (“Mainstream engages in corrupt and
Mainstream Canada
v. Staniford Page 36
immoral behaviour”). Labelling someone as a liar, and
asserting the person is knowingly acting in a way that causes illness and
death, and otherwise is engaging in corrupt and immoral behaviour, is
defamatory.
(iii) Do the words [the
defamatory words] in fact refer to Mainstream?
132,
[141] For these reasons, I
find, therefore, that Mr. Staniford’s words in fact refer to Mainstream.
[142] In summary, I conclude
that Mainstream has proved the essential elements of a defamation claim, namely
that: Mr. Staniford’s words are defamatory, in the sense that they would tend
to lower Mainstream’s reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person; the words
in fact referred to Mainstream; and the words were communicated to at least one
person other than Mainstream.
(b) Mr. Staniford’s
defence of fair comment
[144] Statements of opinion – a
category which has been described as including any deduction, inference,
conclusion, criticism, judgment, remark or observation which is generally
incapable of proof – may attract the defence of fair comment: see Grant,
at para. 31. A defendant claiming fair comment must satisfy the following test:
(a) the comment must be on a matter of public interest; (b) the comment must be
based on fact; (c) the comment, though it can include inferences of fact, must
be recognisable as comment; (d) the comment must satisfy the following
objective test: could any person honestly express that opinion on the proved
facts?; and (e) even
Mainstream Canada v.
Staniford Page 42
[146] “Honest belief” requires
the existence of a relationship between the comment and underlying facts.
(f) if Mr. Staniford was an
honest man expressing his genuine opinion on a subject of public interest then,
no matter that his words conveyed derogatory imputations, no matter that his
opinion was wrong or exaggerated or prejudiced and no matter that it was badly
expressed so that people read all sorts of innuendo into it, nevertheless he
has a good defence of fair comment.
[
[154] However, words that may
appear to be statements of fact may be properly construed as comment. Binnie J.
wrote in WIC, at para. 26:
Mainstream Canada v.
Staniford Page 47
mark the path
towards superior understanding of the world around us."
Mr. Sutherland
argues that there is a direct parallel in this case, and that what Mainstream
is attempting to do by bringing this action is to silence a critic in the face
of scientific controversies.
[166]
This is essentially the argument advanced by Mainstream: that Mr. Staniford’s
statements are verifiable and capable of proof, and therefore must be found to
be statements of fact.
[167] The EWCA did not agree
with Eady J. The court explained the flaw in Eady J’s reasoning, and thus also
a flaw in Mainstream’s argument, in this way (underlining added):
[168] In order for Mr.
Staniford to succeed on his defence of fair comment, it must be shown, with
reasonably clarity, that the words are comment and not statement of fact. The
test is whether the matter would be recognizable to the ordinary
Mainstream Canada v.
Staniford Page 49
[170] However, I have concluded
that the statements are comment, not fact. They reflect Mr. Staniford’s value
judgments – as prejudiced, exaggerated and obstinate as they are – based on
what he has read in the literature and how he has interpreted that literature.
[171] Mr. Staniford’s
statements, such as “Salmon farming kills” and “Salmon farming kills like
smoking,” although they look like statements of fact, can only be – and must be
found to be – statements of opinion. The unexpressed – or not completely
expressed – premise is: “based on this peer-reviewed scientific evidence.” They
must be statements of opinion because there is scientific controversy about the
effect on, and the benefits to, human health from consumption of farmed salmon.
The point is illustrated, and, for my purposes, confirmed by the fact that
different scientists have reached different conclusions, and by Dr. Gallo’s
evidence.
[173] The existence in the
flesh of farmed (and wild) salmon of contaminants that can cause cancer has
been verified as a fact. However, the consequences and effect on human health
of consumption of salmon given that fact is still the subject of debate. In
From
174:
Mr. Staniford’s judgments have
no balance because balance does not exist in Mr. Staniford’s world when it
comes to salmon farming. He has dedicated himself to eradicating it.
(d) since 2000, scientists have
tested farmed and wild salmon and found in the flesh of the fish contaminants
that are capable of causing cancer. The existence of the contaminants has been
established to be true. Dr. Gallo, for example, accepted and did not disagree
with the data used for the Hites Papers;
Mainstream Canada v.
Staniford Page 54
(iv) Could
any person honestly express Mr. Staniford’s opinions based on the proven facts?
[184] I have
concluded the answer to this question must be yes. Mr. Staniford (at least)
believes what he says. He expresses his beliefs in the March 23, 2011 letter to
the King of Norway, and in “Smoke on the Water, Cancer on the Coast.”
Hill and Knowlton used by tobacco firms
[186] I have concluded that Mr. Staniford is akin to a zealot.
Virtually anything that conflicts with his view and vision is wrong, bad,
disgraceful and worse. Individuals who work in the salmon farming industry do
jobs that are “nauseating.” He is highly suspicious. Neutral facts (for
example, that at one time the BCSFA used the public relations firm Hill &
Knowlton to do some work for it) will lead him to jump to irrational
conclusions. Because Hill & Knowlton at one time also did work for members
of “Big Tobacco,” the firm must have been hired because the BCSFA and its
members were engaged in a cover-up, just like Big Tobacco.
[189] I have no doubt that Mr.
Staniford is severely prejudiced when it comes to salmon farming. His views are
exaggerated and obstinate. I express no opinion on whether this makes him an
effective campaigner: that is for others to judge. However, I have concluded
that he honestly believes the opinions he has expressed.
(v) Malice
[190] The defence of fair
comment will fail if the plaintiff proves that the defendant was actuated by
express malice:
Apart from those exceptional
cases, what is required on the part of the defamer to entitle him to the
protection of the privilege is positive belief in the truth of what he
published or, as it is generally though tautologously termed, ‘honest belief’.
If he publishes untrue defamatory matter recklessly, without considering or
caring whether it be true or not, he is in this, as in other branches of the
law, treated as if he knew it to be false.
[195]
[196] On behalf of Mr. Staniford,
Mr. Sutherland argues that Mr. Staniford must be afforded a very broad scope
for speech because his purpose is to end industrial aquaculture. He is a
campaigner attempting to influence public opinion on legitimate public issues.
Therefore, so long as Mr. Staniford’s statements and publications are related
predominantly or primarily to that purpose, it cannot be said that Mr.
Mainstream Canada
v. Staniford Page 58
Staniford is actuated by malice. Mr. Staniford’s loathing of
the aquaculture industry is not unrelated to his purpose, and therefore cannot
constitute malice.
[197] I have concluded above
that Mr. Staniford honestly believes what he says. This finding is inconsistent
with finding that Mr. Staniford said things he knew to be false, or that he was
reckless. However, has Mainstream nevertheless demonstrated that Mr.
Staniford’s dominant purpose in publishing the statements in issue was to
injure Mainstream because of spite or animosity?
The language in his
publications – including the mock cigarette packages in particular – is
extreme, inflammatory, sensationalized, extravagant and violent. The word
“kills” is everywhere.
[200] I have no hesitation,
therefore, in finding that the publications in issue were actuated by Mr.
Staniford’s express malice towards Mainstream.
Mainstream Canada
v. Staniford Page 59
[201] However, I am unable to conclude that this was Mr.
Staniford’s dominant purpose in publishing the statements in issue. Mr.
Staniford’s main goal is to end industrial aquaculture, and he seeks (albeit in
clumsy, crude, irrational or foolish ways) to influence public opinion to that
end. That (currently) is his life’s work. His commitment to that cause is
illustrated by his self-published magnum opus – “Smoke on the Water, Cancer on the Coast.”
[202]
Although I have concluded that Mr. Staniford’s statements are defamatory of
Mainstream, I have concluded that he should succeed on his defence of fair
comment. I have found that he was actuated by express malice towards
Mainstream. However, I have found that he had an honest belief in the
statements he made, and injuring Mainstream because of spite or animosity was
not his dominant purpose in publishing the words in issue.
[203]
In view of those findings, I do not intend to address damages or other
remedies.
[204]
The plaintiff’s action is, accordingly, dismissed.
Sunday, 23 September 2012
Fish Farms Kill Seals and Sea Lions Around the World, Sept 23, 2012
The purpose of this post is to begin making a list of all the countries in the world where fish farms kill pinnipeds, more commonly known as seals and sea lions. No figures are kept for the numbers of sea birds, otters and other animals killed at or by fish farms.
See my earlier post showing than 11,469 seals and sea lions have been killed in BC Canada from 1984 to 2011: http://fishfarmnews.blogspot.com/b/post-preview?token=H-079jkBAAA.RcoTO8mQDOiHL4_fjsIP0Q.AfyGFV8kmoGhfuIWmy-VoA&postId=7900949561164738070&type=POST.
This post shows the 2012 seal kills in Scotland: http://www.robedwards.com/2012/09/sites-where-seals-shot-kept-secret-in-fear-of-protest.html. There have been 310 killed so far.
Marine Harvest operates in 21 countries around the world. So as I begin to track down and put the stats and references here, you will see it is a truly staggering number killed, mostly shot in the head.
Fish farms like to make it sound like the seal is at fault, in various jurisdictions calling them 'nuisance' animals or 'rogue' sea lions. But the problem is not the animal, it is the fish farm. If you dangle food in front of a predator, the predator wants to eat it. That is the problem and the solution is to put fish farms on land where their environmental damage can be contained. Zero sea lions would then be shot in the head.
Countries where fish farms operate include: Ireland, England, Norway, Denland, the USA, Atlantic Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Shetland Islands, Faroe Islands and many others. Check back to this post as it tabulates the grim world wide pinniped kills.
See my earlier post showing than 11,469 seals and sea lions have been killed in BC Canada from 1984 to 2011: http://fishfarmnews.blogspot.com/b/post-preview?token=H-079jkBAAA.RcoTO8mQDOiHL4_fjsIP0Q.AfyGFV8kmoGhfuIWmy-VoA&postId=7900949561164738070&type=POST.
This post shows the 2012 seal kills in Scotland: http://www.robedwards.com/2012/09/sites-where-seals-shot-kept-secret-in-fear-of-protest.html. There have been 310 killed so far.
Marine Harvest operates in 21 countries around the world. So as I begin to track down and put the stats and references here, you will see it is a truly staggering number killed, mostly shot in the head.
Fish farms like to make it sound like the seal is at fault, in various jurisdictions calling them 'nuisance' animals or 'rogue' sea lions. But the problem is not the animal, it is the fish farm. If you dangle food in front of a predator, the predator wants to eat it. That is the problem and the solution is to put fish farms on land where their environmental damage can be contained. Zero sea lions would then be shot in the head.
Countries where fish farms operate include: Ireland, England, Norway, Denland, the USA, Atlantic Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Shetland Islands, Faroe Islands and many others. Check back to this post as it tabulates the grim world wide pinniped kills.
Tuesday, 17 July 2012
Key Document: Fish Farms Damage Ocean Bottoms
This is a report on Shelburne Bay, NS, fish farming in 2012, prepared by Inka Milewski on damage to the bottom of the ocean:http://www.friendsofshelburneharbour.org/uploads/McGregorMilewskiSandyPointApr2012.pdf.
I post this out as it is current report and typical of the damage caused by fish farms to the bottom of the ocean, taking, in some cases more than a decade to recover once fish farms have been pulled out.
Milewski says that: "in her decades of research in the area, she has seen regular outbreaks of infectious salmon anemia (ISA), sea lice infect caged salmon populations in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. In February, Cooke Aquaculture was forced to slaughter 700,000 salmon in Shelburne Harbour and last week a firm in Newfoundland was ordered by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency to slaughter more ISA-infected fish. [July, 2012]
I post this out as it is current report and typical of the damage caused by fish farms to the bottom of the ocean, taking, in some cases more than a decade to recover once fish farms have been pulled out.
Milewski says that: "in her decades of research in the area, she has seen regular outbreaks of infectious salmon anemia (ISA), sea lice infect caged salmon populations in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia. In February, Cooke Aquaculture was forced to slaughter 700,000 salmon in Shelburne Harbour and last week a firm in Newfoundland was ordered by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency to slaughter more ISA-infected fish. [July, 2012]
"In April, Milewski sent a copy of the report and her findings to Fisheries
and Aquaculture Minister Sterling Belliveau, with an invitation to meet with him
to discuss her findings. She said that, to date, she has had no response to her
offer." See this article:
She also says: "The government must release all environmental
monitoring data for all existing salmon farm sites, says Milewski.
“If the province can’t publicly produce environmental monitoring data from
existing fish farms in a timely manner,” she says, “They certainly can’t be
relied upon to act when environmental damage is being done by these
farms”."
The report is a stinging indictment of fish farming, and is typical of conditions found around the world. The issue that has not yet been measured is how the water column is infected with trillions of viral particles for many miles in both directions that the tide flows. This is particularly problemmatic in bays and sounds, like Shelburne and Clayoquot Sound, BC, because they have one closed end and thus to not flush.
Google:Environmental damage under fish farms: http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=environmental+damage+under+fish+farms&oq=environmental+damage+under+fish+farms&gs_l=youtube.3...11321429.11332371.0.11332658.74.42.4.8.9.6.242.4296.21j18j2.42.0...0.0...1ac.jxeGnlW81Sc,
to see how fish farms destroy the ocean bottom with sewage and feed, making them dead zones in many locations.
Google:Youtube video on sea bottoms under fish farms: http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ocean+bottoms+under+fish+farms&sa=X&spell=1&search=Search&oi=spell.There are move videos on sea bottom damage on YouTube, these are just sample videos. In fairness there are a few, well selected sites, by fish farms.
As hard as it maybe to believe, Belliveau has just awarded Cooke Aquaculture $25 million to expand. This at the same time that they are charged with using the lobster killing and illegal chemical cypermethrin to kill lice. These charges may bring millions in fines and jail sentences. Cooke, in its court case, has said it wants to 'study the evidence', and thus has taken the subject out of the news. This is a very typical ploy by charged fish farms around the world, and in this case it is shameful that Belliveau came up with the $25 at a time when Cooke is charged and has had to slaughter. Just shameful.
Thursday, 5 July 2012
Key Document - Fish Farm Diseases That Infect Humans - July 5, 2012
This post will grow over time, so check back from time to time, as I put the new update date in the title.
Do remember that most cold water viruses do not affect humans, however, the issue is that fish farms, due to their density of fish, cause mutations in viruses. There are also fungal and bacterial diseases in farmed fish, several dozen in total.
1. Google: fish farm diseases that infect humans and you will be reading for days: https://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&site=&source=hp&q=fish+farm+diseases+that+infect+humans&oq=fish+farm+diseases+that+infect+humans&gs_l=hp.4...421.6609.0.7472.37.35.0.0.0.0.269.3750.14j20j1.35.0...0.0.zV5g8os4OMk.
2. Kudoa septempunctata. This is not the Kudoa species that has been found in Marine Harvest BC farmed salmon. It is a relative, and has been shown to make more than 1300 people in Japan sick from eating raw fish. See: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22281845.
3. Fish diseases that infect humans: http://mudiparofarms.com/?p=90.
4. Asian fish product diseases that infect humans. See this for liver flukes and trematodes: http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/15/4/08-1147_article.htm.
5. A long list of diseases that fish transmit to humans: http://www.scribd.com/doc/3699145/Disease-Trasmitted-From-Fish-to-Human.Note that these are not necessarily from fish farms, just from fish.
Do remember that most cold water viruses do not affect humans, however, the issue is that fish farms, due to their density of fish, cause mutations in viruses. There are also fungal and bacterial diseases in farmed fish, several dozen in total.
1. Google: fish farm diseases that infect humans and you will be reading for days: https://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&site=&source=hp&q=fish+farm+diseases+that+infect+humans&oq=fish+farm+diseases+that+infect+humans&gs_l=hp.4...421.6609.0.7472.37.35.0.0.0.0.269.3750.14j20j1.35.0...0.0.zV5g8os4OMk.
2. Kudoa septempunctata. This is not the Kudoa species that has been found in Marine Harvest BC farmed salmon. It is a relative, and has been shown to make more than 1300 people in Japan sick from eating raw fish. See: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22281845.
3. Fish diseases that infect humans: http://mudiparofarms.com/?p=90.
4. Asian fish product diseases that infect humans. See this for liver flukes and trematodes: http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/15/4/08-1147_article.htm.
5. A long list of diseases that fish transmit to humans: http://www.scribd.com/doc/3699145/Disease-Trasmitted-From-Fish-to-Human.Note that these are not necessarily from fish farms, just from fish.
Wednesday, 4 July 2012
BAP Awards Not Awards - Updated July 5, 2012
July 5, 2012. One day after Marine Harvest took credit, as below, for BAP certification in BC, CTV has reported on fish farm diseases: Marine Harvest alone spent $12 million last year to clear out infected fish [Kudoa] and provide refunds
for tainted products, and there are estimates that Kudoa affects 20 to
50 per cent of all salmon farmed in the province.
Read this:http://bc.ctvnews.ca/parasite-ridden-salmon-sold-in-b-c-stores-1.864202.
So, what is it that BAP awards mean? Not much.
Now, read my July 4 post on the BAPs
Read this: http://www.canada.com/Marine+Harvest+gets+certification/6880995/story.html.
Read this:http://bc.ctvnews.ca/parasite-ridden-salmon-sold-in-b-c-stores-1.864202.
So, what is it that BAP awards mean? Not much.
Now, read my July 4 post on the BAPs
Read this: http://www.canada.com/Marine+Harvest+gets+certification/6880995/story.html.
Marine Harvest et al have been trumpeting the past couple of weeks around the globe in news reports about receiving the really worthwhile BAP awards. The problem is that the BAPs are not awards at all.
The industry got together and made the organization then they all put money into it. And they now get the BAP certification from themselves. Don't be fooled. Nothing has changed. Fish farms only want to be in the ocean to use it as a free, open sewer.They should be on land.
You may recall it is only a couple of weeks since 7 fish farms in BC and Washington tested positive for viral diseases. And remember that at the recent Cohen Commission in December, 2011 testimony showed that 25% of Clayoquot farmed chinook tested positive for HSMI and ISA. (This is a huge problem for wild fish, and my bet is that the Clayoquot Sound chinook and Kennedy Lake sockeye are in trouble because of billions of viruses in the non-flushing Sound).
In truth, Marine Harvest Canada is in trouble. It lost money in Q1, of 2012, -.6%, its only major operation around the world to post a loss. And they let go 60 employees at Christmas time. And are reducing orders for smolts.
And, by the way, the CEO of Marine Harvest, Alf Helge, in Norway has just complained about fish farms refusal to bring forth sea lice data. See: http://viewer.zmags.com/publication/84be8a79#/84be8a79/16.
You see, 40% of farms don't report lice and the government
doesn't follow up. Meanwhile, here in BC Canada, Marine Harvest has just pulled out of a joint study with environmental groups studying, wait for it, ... that sea lice do not cause problems with wild fish or transfer diseases. Same fish farm company, completely different response.
What Marine Harvest did get out of the five year agreement with the Suzuki Foundation and so on in BC is not being criticized in the press. I would say that lucky outcome has ended.
Oh, and you will remember that Marine Harvest plead guilty in December of 2011 of having wild salmon and herring in its nets in BC - having for almost two years previous, protested its innocence. And in Ireland, Scotland and Norway, in the past year nearly 500,000 farmed salmon escaped from fish farms. Hmm.
The BAPs don't mean much.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)